Bringhurst: Joe Rogan is Spreading Dangerous COVID-19 Misinformation
September 14, 2021
A typical day in Joe Rogan’s life starts at the gym, followed by mushroom coffee and supplements such as creatine and Alpha Brain. He sticks to a strict diet founded in “primal” eating.
Dude-bros around the world drool over his intellectual conversations and cheer along when he calls out political correctness. And worst of all, people listened when he promoted Ivermectin, a drug that prevents parasites in livestock, as an effective COVID-19 treatment to his large audience.
Rogan has a moral responsibility to provide accurate information to his audience, particularly regarding a virus as polarizing and devastating as COVID-19. Failing to recognize his actions is reckless, as is already demonstrated in its consequences.
Public figures have cashed in on public interest in conspiracy theories for a while now. As media becomes more saturated and the line between news and entertainment blurs, it becomes easier for seemingly credible figures to present misleading information. A polarized environment and a general distrust in the government results in widespread acceptance of alternative facts — especially during the pandemic.
Dr. Joseph Mercola, an osteopathic physician and prominent spreader of COVID-19 misinformation, is an excellent example of this. Since 2005, he has successfully profited from skepticism and alternative medicine. In 2012, he claimed tanning beds reduced the likelihood of cancer while selling tanning beds, resulting in penalization from the Federal Trade Commission for false advertising.
But his shady history doesn’t deter his modern audience, who cite him as a trustworthy source for anti-vaccination sentiment. “He takes away from the idea that an anti-vaccination activist is a fringe person,” Kolina Kaltai, a conspiracy theory researcher at the University of Washington, said in an interview with the New York Times.
Rogan’s 11 million YouTube subscriber count acts as a stamp of credibility in the eyes of viewers. Social media accounts held by anti-vaxxers have increased their following by at least 7 million people since 2019, according to a report by The Centre for Countering Digital Hate. Rogan’s suggestions that young people don’t need to get vaccinated and the use of Ivermectin will effectively treat COVID-19 are dangerous.
A study done on the effectiveness of Ivermectin as a COVID-19 treatment stopped after results were determined unviable. “We do not see the treatment benefits that a lot of advocates believe there should have been,” said Dr. Edward Mills, the professor at McMaster University who led the study.
He noted that the study would’ve ended earlier when a single dose made no difference. But persistence and threats from advocate groups elicited them to raise the trial to three doses. Still, the horse dewormer was just as effective as the placebo.
Philosopher Immanuel Kant said lying is always morally wrong because false information prevents humans from making informed decisions. Rogan may not have intentionally lied when he suggested young people don’t need to get vaccinated and Ivermectin will treat COVID-19. However, the results from Dr. Mills’ study became publicly available almost a month before Rogan gave the drug his personal endorsement. He had the opportunity to educate his audience, but instead chose to promote a drug the FDA advised against.
Whether or not celebrities have a moral obligation to use their platforms responsibly is an ongoing conversation. People criticize models for promoting harmful detox teas and unrealistic body standards. Promoting these ideals to impressionable young people has consequences, because people trust their idols and tend to take their word as truth. We should criticize celebrities who spread misinformation, especially when the consequences can be lethal.
So far, Texas has seen a 150% increase in poison control calls from people using Ivermectin in 2021. Some rural Americans already have it for agricultural purposes. Why pay for an expensive visit to the doctor when you have the treatment on hand? The FDA said it has “received multiple reports of patients who have required medical attention, including hospitalization, after self-medicating with Ivermectin intended for livestock.”
Though doctors will sometimes prescribe it in small amounts primarily intended to treat parasites, the FDA has not authorized Ivermectin to treat COVID-19. Even if future findings prove Ivermectin can relieve COVID-19 symptoms, it isn’t considered safe now. And it wasn’t when Rogan recklessly endorsed it to millions of impressionable listeners.
Humans have flaws, and we can’t expect superhuman diligence from celebrities. Everyone has an individual responsibility to research vaccine effectiveness and to seek verifiable truth to formulate an educated opinion. But the term “influencer” was coined for a reason — and it’s vital for anyone with an audience to wield their influence responsibly.
Brian James • Dec 14, 2021 at 1:41 pm
Oh great, a 3rd year journalism college student giving opinions on covid treatments.
John Hedberg • Sep 16, 2021 at 3:15 pm
President Joe Biden recently gave a speech saying that vaccinated Americans are running out of patience, and that this pandemic, and its HORRIFIC effects, are now considered the fault of the unvaccinated by his government, thereby targeting the wrath of the fearful onto this whole population without reason or cause or conscience.
CDC Director Rochelle Walensky reversed her previous mask recommendations on July 30th, after it was discovered that the vaccinated are not only getting the virus in high numbers, but their high viral load transmits the virus to others, so it was necessary to recommend masks again to stop the vaccinated from spreading the virus to the unvaccinated. I’ll say that again: she recommended masks again for the vaccinated to stop them from spreading the virus to the unvaccinated, not the other way around. https://www.cdc.gov/media/releases/2021/s0730-mmwr-covid-19.html
Utah’s coronavirus website (under Risk Factors) indicates that in the last 30 days, vaccinated Utahns have constituted between 10-20% of new COVID cases daily, and they obviously transmit the disease. Anyone can now clearly see that the vaccines last less than 6 months and don’t really prevent infection, so this has many Utahns asking why they should take the risk, particularly Pacific Islanders (40.6% vaccinated), African Americans (39.7% vaccinated), and Native Americans (35.7% vaccinated with at least one dose), from the same Utah website (under Vaccines), as of 16 September. https://coronavirus.utah.gov/case-counts/ .
People are beginning to wonder why the President is still calling this a pandemic of the unvaccinated, and stoking fear and rage against innocent people of all demographics who find vaccines risky, when his own CDC Director says he’s lying and stoking hate against innocent people, meanwhile telling innocent people that their bigotry is a threat to democracy.
😀
All the Best, With Love,
J
M. Freedman • Sep 15, 2021 at 10:17 pm
This article is false and dangerously misleading.
Peoples lives are at stake.
Ivermectin is highly effective.
https://www.wnd.com/2021/09/major-nation-credits-maligned-horse-dewormer-dramatic-victory-covid/?utm_source=Email&utm_medium=wnd-breaking&utm_campaign=breaking&utm_content=breaking&ats_es=%5B-MD5-%5D
Matthew Hall • Sep 15, 2021 at 4:16 am
Whole countries have used Ivermectin with great success, principally as a prophylactic. Most Indian states (after the recent outbreak), Mexico, Peru, Colombia and many others.
This is a complex issue. Joe does a great job of promoting discussion. Thank God for him.
gabe rocco • Sep 14, 2021 at 9:32 pm
Junkies like Rogan, who dupe their audiences into believing, all that energy Joe has must be how he lives.
Wrong, Joe’s energy, like all doctor shoppers (think of Elvis) gets whatever prescription he wants, steroids, HGH and testosterone.
That’s Joe’s “energy” drug abuse, just like Elvis.
Yet Incel face after Incel face, Proud Boys loser after Proud Boys loser, Paedo after paedo they adore, love Joe Rogan.
And the filth he nurtures.